Hansard Search

12 March 1991 - Current

 
MEDICAL TREATMENT (PHYSICIAN ASSISTED DYING) BILL
Page 3616
10 September 2008
COUNCIL Second Reading PRESIDENT
  The PRESIDENT -- Order! I remind not only the house  but the gallery that this
debate is being conducted in a dignified manner.

We are about to embark on a vote the result of which will be  known in the  next
few minutes. I expect the gallery to respond in exactly the same dignified way.
House divided on amendment:
                                    Ayes, 9
Atkinson, Mr                  O'Donohue, Mr
Barber, Mr                    Pennicuik, Ms
Coote, Mrs (Teller)           Petrovich, Mrs (Teller)
Davis, Mr P.                  Rich-Phillips, Mr
Hartland, Ms
                                    Noes, 30
Broad, Ms                     Lovell, Ms
Dalla-Riva, Mr                Madden, Mr

Darveniza, Ms                 Mikakos, Ms
Davis, Mr D.                  Pakula, Mr
Drum, Mr                      Peulich, Mrs
Eideh, Mr                     Pulford, Ms
Elasmar, Mr                   Scheffer, Mr
Finn, Mr                      Smith, Mr
Hall, Mr                      Somyurek, Mr
Jennings, Mr                  Tee, Mr
Kavanagh, Mr (Teller)         Theophanous, Mr
Koch, Mr                      Thornley, Mr (Teller)
Kronberg, Mrs                 Tierney, Ms
Leane, Mr                     Viney, Mr
Lenders, Mr                   Vogels, Mr
Amendment negatived.


  The PRESIDENT -- Order!  The question is that  the  bill be now read  a second
time.
House divided on motion:
                                    Ayes, 13
Barber, Mr                    Koch, Mr
Broad, Ms (Teller)            Leane, Mr
Coote, Mrs                    O'Donohue, Mr
Davis, Mr P. (Teller)         Pennicuik, Ms
Hall, Mr                      Scheffer, Mr
Hartland, Ms                  Tierney, Ms
Jennings, Mr
                                    Noes, 25

Atkinson, Mr (Teller)         Pakula, Mr
Dalla-Riva, Mr                Petrovich, Mrs
Davis, Mr D.                  Peulich, Mrs
Drum, Mr                      Pulford, Ms
Eideh, Mr                     Rich-Phillips, Mr
Elasmar, Mr                   Smith, Mr
Finn, Mr                      Somyurek, Mr
Kavanagh, Mr                  Tee, Mr
Kronberg, Mrs                 Theophanous, Mr
Lenders, Mr                   Thornley, Mr
Lovell, Ms                    Viney, Mr
Madden, Mr                    Vogels, Mr
Mikakos, Ms (Teller) 
Motion negatived.